Yusuf v. Vigyapan Loke Delhi Advertising C.G.H.S. Ltd
2026 INSC 1207 | Civil Appeal No. 14175 of 2026
In brief and case details
Balance-sheet entries carrying a debt forward can be an acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, so a plaint relying on them cannot be rejected as time-barred under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
1 Leave granted.
2 The present appeal is filed against the judgment and final order dated 04.11.2024 passed by the High Court of Delhi in C.R.P. No.66 of 2020 whereby the High Court allowed the Revision Petition filed by the defendant-respondent and rejeceted the plaint filed by the plaintiff-appellant as barred by limitation. For convenience, the parties shall be referred to by their respective positions before the Trial Court.
3 Brief facts giving rise to the appeal are as follows:
3.1 The original plaintiff, Wazir Hussain, instituted a suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, CPC) in 2014 seeking recovery of money due under a civil works contract dated 10.02.2000. The contract was entered into by the defendant-society (hereinafter referred to as ‘defendant’) for construction work to be carried out by the original plaintiff in connection with a multi-story building in Mayur Vihar, Delhi. He relied on running bills raised between 2000 and 2003 to seek recovery of Rs. 11,16,000/- along with interest of Rs. 11,04,840/- calculated at 9% p.a., and pendente lite and future interest at the same rate until realization.
3.2 The defendant filed an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC seeking rejection of the plaint. It contended, inter alia, that the suit was barred by limitation, did not disclose a cause of action and was not maintainable in view of alleged embezzlement.
3.3 By order dated 06.01.2020, the Trial Court rejected the application. The Court observed that the outstanding amounts were being reflected in the balance sheets of the defendant-Society for the years 2004, 2005 till 2013, which amounts to acknowledgment of debt consequently giving rise to a fresh period of limitation. It further noted that the other issues regarding maintainability and genuineness of bills were questions requiring evidence.
3.4 Aggrieved, the defendant preferred a revision petition before the High Court. It primarily contended that the suit instituted in 2014 in respect of transactions dating back to 2000 and 2003 was barred by limitation.
3.5 By the impugned order dated 04.11.2024, the High Court allowed the revision petition and rejected the plaint as being barred by limitation. It observed that the bank statements relied upon by the plaintiff did not establish an acknowledgment of liability extending beyond 2005. It further noted that there was no balance sheet or any other document produced by the plaintiff showing any kind of acknowledgment.
3.6 Aggrieved, the legal heir of the original plaintiff is here before us.
4 We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and examined the material placed on record.
5 The limited question before us is whether in the face of entries of defendant’s balance sheets up to 2013, the suit could have been rejected at threshold as being barred by limitation.
6 It is not in dispute that the running bills relied upon by the original plaintiff pertain to the period from 2000 and 2003. The defendant had also issued cheques in favour of the original plaintiff, which were dishonoured. The plaintiff’s case, however, is not founded solely on these transactions. He relies on the entries in the balance sheets of defendant-Society which as per him continued to reflect the amounts pertaining to the financial year 2004-05 up to the financial year 2012-13.
7 The original plaintiff contended that the continued reflection of these amounts in the Society’s accounts, more particularly in the entry dated 31.03.2013, constituted an acknowledgment of liability. On this basis, he asserted that a fresh period of limitation began from the date of acknowledgment reflected in the balance sheet entries. Therefore, the suit could not have been rejected as being time-barred.
8 The High Court took note of the bank entries relied upon by the original plaintiff, however refused to treat them as acknowledgment of amount due to be payable. It observed that the balance sheet as on 31.03.2013 reflected an amount of Rs.21,79,465/- under the head of sundry creditors pertaining to the year 2004-05, but it did not in any way indicate that the amount was due and payable to the original plaintiff. It similarly observed that the balance sheet for 2004-05 and the bank reconciliation statement which made a reference to the cheques issued in original plaintiff’s favour, also did not record any acknowledgment of liability of the Society.
9 In order to understand the effect of the balance sheet entries of 2013, we have to turn to Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963. It states the following:
“18. Effect of acknowledgment in writing.- (1) Where, before the expiration of the prescribed period for a suit or application in respect of any property or right, an acknowledgment of liability in respect of such property or right has been made in writing signed by the party against whom such property or right is claimed, or by any person through whom he derives his title or liability, a fresh period of limitation shall be computed from the time when the acknowledgment was so signed. …”
Simply stated, a written acknowledgment of a subsisting liability gives rise to a fresh period of limitation, commencing from the date on which the acknowledgment is made. In effect, the period of limitation is renewed, or extended.
10 In Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd. v. Bishal Jaiswal1, a three-judge bench of this Court held that entries in books of account, including balance sheets, may constitute an acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of Limitation Act. However, it also provided a caveat to the effect that the said entry must be assessed in the context of the balance sheet as a whole, including any qualifications or explanations contained in the accompanying notes or auditor’s report.
11 The same principle was reiterated in Axis Bank Ltd. v. Naren Sheth2 wherein this Court recognized that Section 18 of Limitation Act would apply in case of balance sheets acknowledging a debt.
12 In the present case, the original plaintiff relies on the defendant-Society’s balance sheet for the year 2004-05 and the bank reconciliation statements for the same financial year. The latter explicitly records three cheques issued in favour of ‘Wazir Hussain Contractor’. These entries directly connect the original plaintiff with the Society’s financial records and transactions underlying the suit.
13 The plaintiff further relies on defendant-Society’s balance sheets for the subsequent financial years wherein an amount of Rs.21,79,134/- continued to be carried forward under the head ‘Balances pertaining to 2004-05’. As per him, the amount claimed in the suit formed a part of the amount reflected in the balance sheets, read cumulatively with the cheques and bank reconciliation statements. As such, it constituted an acknowledgment of liability from 2005 onwards.
14 Section 18 of the Limitation Act does not require that an acknowledgment be made to the name of the creditor specifically or be drawn up using a fixed format, so long as it acknowledges a subsisting liability. The only requirement is that the acknowledgment, when read in conjunction with the other circumstances surrounding the transaction, must indicate a subsisting jural relationship. In the present set of facts, the surrounding circumstances amply support the claim of the original plaintiff that a liability existed, that it was reflected in defendant’s own balance sheets and that the same continued to be carried forward to the year 2013, renewing the limitation period every year.
15 The above discussion is not to be read to mean that the entries conclusively establish that the entire amount as is claimed in the suit was owed to the original plaintiff. The precise relationship between the cheques issued, amounts carried forward and the sum claimed, inter alia, would require examination of evidence. These are matters for trial. At the stage of considering an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court ought not to have gone into the depths of evidence and conclusively determined the non-existence of liability. It was required only to assess whether the plaint disclosed a prima facie case on the basis of the material available.
16 The defendant’s contention that a time-barred debt cannot be revived indefinitely, more particularly so in the absence of an application seeking condonation of delay, cannot be sustained. Since the entries constitute an acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, a fresh period of limitation would automatically run from each subsequent date of acknowledgment. In that event, there was no requirement for an application seeking condonation of delay.
17 In light of the above discussion, we are of the view that the High Court fell in error in allowing the defendant’s revision petition and rejecting the plaint as being barred by limitation. The impugned order is accordingly set aside. The suit shall stand revived on the file of the Trial Court. All questions on the merits of the claim shall remain open.
18 The appeal is accordingly allowed.
19 Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
Text of the judgment as published by the Supreme Court of India. Official PDF on sci.gov.in. Links to sections, judgments and judges were added by OneCourt. If a link is wrong, please let us know.
Summary
The original plaintiff, a contractor, filed a summary suit in 2014 against the respondent society to recover Rs 11.16 lakh with interest for construction work under a contract of 10 Feb 2000, relying on running bills of 2000 to 2003. The Trial Court refused to reject the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, holding that the society's balance sheets up to 2013 acknowledged the debt. The High Court of Delhi allowed the society's revision and rejected the plaint as barred by limitation. The plaintiff's legal heir appealed by special leave.
Allowing the appeal, the Court held that entries in a debtor's balance sheets can be an acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963, following Bishal Jaiswal and Naren Sheth. An acknowledgment need not name the creditor or follow a fixed form, so long as, read with the surrounding circumstances, it shows a subsisting jural relationship. Here the society's balance sheet and bank reconciliation statement for 2004-05 recorded cheques issued to the contractor, and the amount was carried forward to 2013, renewing limitation each year. Whether the whole sum was owed is a matter for trial, not for an Order VII Rule 11 application. The suit was revived.
Facts
The society engaged the original plaintiff, Wazir Hussain, under a civil works contract of 10 Feb 2000 to build a multi-storey building in Mayur Vihar, Delhi. In 2014 he filed a suit under Order XXXVII CPC for Rs 11,16,000 with interest of Rs 11,04,840 at 9% a year, relying on running bills raised between 2000 and 2003. Cheques the society issued to him had been dishonoured.
The society applied under Order VII Rule 11 CPC to reject the plaint, saying the suit was time-barred, disclosed no cause of action and was not maintainable because of alleged embezzlement. On 6 Jan 2020 the Trial Court dismissed the application: the outstanding amounts appeared in the society's balance sheets for 2004 to 2013, which was an acknowledgment of debt.
On 4 Nov 2024 the High Court allowed the society's revision (C.R.P. No. 66 of 2020) and rejected the plaint as time-barred. It held that the balance sheet as on 31 Mar 2013, which showed Rs 21,79,465 under sundry creditors for 2004-05, did not show that the amount was payable to the plaintiff, and that the 2004-05 balance sheet and bank reconciliation statement recorded no acknowledgment.
The original plaintiff's legal heir appealed by special leave.
Issues
- With entries in the society's balance sheets up to 2013, could the suit be rejected at the threshold as barred by limitation?
- Can balance-sheet entries that do not name the creditor be an acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act?
- Was an application for condonation of delay needed?
Held
- Entries in books of account, including balance sheets, may be an acknowledgment of liability under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, assessed in the context of the balance sheet as a whole.
- Section 18 does not require the acknowledgment to name the creditor or follow a fixed format. It must, read with the surrounding circumstances, show a subsisting jural relationship.
- The society's 2004-05 balance sheet and bank reconciliation statement recorded three cheques to 'Wazir Hussain Contractor', and the amount was carried forward under 'Balances pertaining to 2004-05' up to 2013. This supported a subsisting liability, renewing limitation every year.
- On an Order VII Rule 11 application the court asks only whether the plaint discloses a prima facie case on the material available. It should not go into the evidence and conclusively find that no liability exists.
- Since each entry was an acknowledgment, a fresh period of limitation ran from each date, and no application for condonation of delay was needed.
Result: Appeal allowed. The High Court's order is set aside, the suit is revived before the Trial Court, and all questions on the merits remain open.
Reasoning
- The Court read Section 18: a written acknowledgment of a subsisting liability, signed before the limitation period expires, starts a fresh period from the date it is signed.
- It followed the three-judge bench in Bishal Jaiswal (balance-sheet entries can be an acknowledgment, read with the notes and the auditor's report) and Naren Sheth.
- The plaintiff's case did not rest only on the bills of 2000 to 2003. The cheques in the 2004-05 records tied him to the society's accounts, and the carried-forward balance kept the liability alive to 2013.
- The exact link between the cheques, the carried-forward amount and the sum claimed needs evidence and was left to the trial.
Directions
- The High Court's order of 4 Nov 2024 is set aside.
- The suit stands revived on the file of the Trial Court.
- All questions on the merits of the claim remain open.
Points to note
- Ratio: Entries in a debtor's balance sheets that carry forward a liability can be an acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, even without naming the creditor, if the surrounding circumstances show a subsisting jural relationship. Each such entry starts a fresh period of limitation.
- Follows Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd. v. Bishal Jaiswal (2021 INSC 254) and Axis Bank Ltd. v. Naren Sheth (2023 INSC 820).
- At the Order VII Rule 11 stage the court looks only for a prima facie case on the plaint and its documents; disputed questions about the amount owed go to trial.
- Where limitation is saved by acknowledgment, no application for condonation of delay is needed.
- Left open: whether the whole amount claimed was owed to the plaintiff, and all other questions on the merits.
Law applied
Statutes and provisions
- Limitation Act, 1963: Section 18 (effect of acknowledgment in writing)
- Code of Civil Procedure, 1908: Order VII Rule 11 (rejection of plaint)
- Code of Civil Procedure, 1908: Order XXXVII (summary suit)
Cases relied on or distinguished
| Case | Citation | How it was used |
|---|---|---|
| Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd. v. Bishal Jaiswal | 2021 INSC 254 | Followed. Entries in books of account, including balance sheets, may be an acknowledgment under Section 18, read with the balance sheet as a whole, its notes and the auditor's report. |
| Axis Bank Ltd. v. Naren Sheth | 2023 INSC 820 | Followed. Section 18 applies to balance sheets acknowledging a debt. |
This summary was prepared from the judgment published by the Supreme Court of India. It is a guide, not legal advice and not a substitute for the judgment itself. Read the full judgment on sci.gov.in.
AI tools were used to improve this page. If something is wrong, please let us know.